Useless fitness. 5 popular gym exercises that are badly overrated

MV
Mark Voronsky

Half of gym visitors tread water for months and never see definition simply because they blindly copy someone else's workouts. Many iconic moves that became the gold standard of the weight room turned out empty. They do not burn fat, do not grow muscle, yet they hammer your joints and steal precious time.

Gym training. Photo: Unsplash
Gym training. Photo: Unsplash

Classic floor crunches

Millions of people still lie on a mat and frantically work their abs hoping to burn belly fat. That is the industry's main and most stubborn myth. Spot reduction does not exist: the body loses fat as a whole when there is a calorie deficit, and crunches do nothing to the layer around the waist.

Abdominal crunch on the floor. Photo: Unsplash
Abdominal crunch on the floor. Photo: Unsplash

Worse, the move has a very small range of motion and isolates only the rectus abdominis. If you also lock your hands behind your head and yank yourself by the neck, instead of a steel midsection you get a huge, dangerous load on the cervical spine.

Dumbbell side bends

An exercise that flooded gyms thanks to women dreaming of a slim waist. The logic is simple: lean sideways with a heavy dumbbell and the love handles will leave.

Dumbbell side bend. Photo: Unsplash
Dumbbell side bend. Photo: Unsplash

The effect is the opposite. Side bends make the obliques grow. As a result your waist does not shrink; it widens and makes the torso more square. An extra "bonus" is unnatural side compression of the spinal discs under load, which sooner or later leads to a neurologist visit.

Smith machine squats

The Smith machine is often sold to beginners as a safer alternative to free-bar squats. In reality the rigidly fixed bar path is a trap for the joints.

Smith machine squat. Photo: Unsplash
Smith machine squat. Photo: Unsplash

When someone squats with a free bar, the body moves along a natural, slightly arcing path, and hundreds of small stabilizer muscles hold balance. In the Smith machine the path is strictly vertical. The body has to adapt to the metal frame, which loads the knees and lower back. Stabilizers drop out of the work entirely.

Seated hip abduction machine

A hugely popular machine in the women's area, with a queue around it. It is supposed to "tone the outer thighs" and round the glutes.

In reality the move only hits the small and medium glute muscles, and in a very unphysiological seated position. The load is isolated and minimal. If you want strong shape in the legs and glutes, basic lunges, Romanian deadlifts, or glute bridges work far better, because the whole lower body works together.

Seated leg extensions

People love this exercise because it is easy to pump the front of the thigh (quadriceps). The muscle really burns, but the price of that burn is too high. Seated leg extensions create so-called anterior tibial translation. All the load from the heavy pad you push up lands on the knee ligaments, especially the cruciate.

For professional bodybuilders in a cutting phase the move can make sense, but for an ordinary person who came for health and shape, the knee risk outweighs any benefit. Swap it for squats or a leg press.

All stories: Body